2018 - Pizza Challenge - Winner People's Choice

2017 - Pizza Challenge - Runner Up People's Choice

2016 - Pizza Challenge - Runners Up People's Choice

2015 - Pizza Challenge - Winner People's Choice

2014 - Pizza Challenge - Winner Pizza Palooza

2013 - Pizza Challenge - Runner Up Pizza Palooza

2012 - Pizza Challenge - Winner Pizza Palooza

2011 - Pizza Challenge - Winner Pizza Palooza

2011 - Pizza Challenge - Winner People's Choice

2010 - Pizza Challenge - Winner Pizza Palooza

2010 - Pizza Challenge - Winner People's Choice

2007 - Toledo City Paper - Winner People's Choice

2006 - Pizza Challenge - Winner People's Choice

2006 - Toledo City Paper - Winner People's Choice

2005 - Pizza Challenge - Winner People's Choice

2005 - Pizza Challenge - Winner Specialty Pizza

2004 - Pizza Challenge - Winner People's Choice

2004 - Pizza Challenge - Winner Specialty Pizza

2003 - Pizza Challenge - Winner People's Choice

2003 - Pizza Challenge - Winner Specialty Pizza

2003 - Toledo City Paper - Winner People's Choice

2002 - Pizza Challenge - Winner People's Choice

2002 - Pizza Challenge - Winner Specialty Pizza

2002 - Toledo City Paper - Winner People's Choice

2001 - Pizza Challenge - Winner People's Choice

2001 - Pizza Challenge - Winner Specialty Pizza

2001 - Toledo City Paper - Winner People's Choice

2000 - Pizza Challenge - Winner People's Choice

2000 - Toledo City Paper - Winner People's Choice